Prime Roof Repairs Company Toronto vs High Skillz Roofing Inc.: which fits a skylight job?
Prime Roof Repairs Company Toronto and High Skillz Roofing Inc. in North York both score near the top of the field, and both are legitimate options for skylight work, but they're built for slightly different jobs. This comparison, based on our methodology, looks at which one actually fits a skylight repair versus a bigger roofing project.
The differences that matter
- Skylight-specific track record. Prime Roof Repairs' reviews explicitly cite skylight leak repairs alongside roof work, while High Skillz's reviews center on roof leaks and replacements without singling out skylights.
- Diagnose-first vs replace-first. Prime Roof Repairs is called out for telling customers when no repair was actually needed, which matters for a skylight leak that could be flashing, sealant, or something else entirely; High Skillz's praise centers on fair pricing rather than diagnostic honesty specifically.
- Typical job size. Prime Roof Repairs leans toward urgent, targeted fixes (leaks, storm damage, skylights) completed the same day, while High Skillz is more often praised for full single-day roof replacements.
- Lead tech vs owner-led crew. Prime Roof Repairs' jobs are led personally by Arsen with fast dispatch, whereas High Skillz's jobs run through owner Arthur, who stays directly involved and responsive throughout.
Side by side
- Google rating
- Prime Roof Repair: 5 (216 reviews)
- High Skillz Roofing Inc.: 5 (213 reviews)
- Services
- Prime Roof Repair: roof inspection maintenance, roofing contractor, roof replacement installation, siding contractor
- High Skillz Roofing Inc.: roof inspection maintenance, roofing contractor, roof replacement installation, siding contractor
- Best fit for a skylight leak
- Prime Roof Repair: Direct skylight repair experience cited in reviews
- High Skillz Roofing Inc.: General roof leak and storm response, no specific skylight mentions
- Primary specialty
- Prime Roof Repair: Emergency leak triage, skylights, storm/ice dam repair
- High Skillz Roofing Inc.: Full roof replacements and general repairs
- Verification
- Prime Roof Repair: Google-verified
- High Skillz Roofing Inc.: Google-verified
- Composite score
- Prime Roof Repair: 94
- High Skillz Roofing Inc.: 94
Within 3 points of each other, so treat them as effectively tied on overall quality. The choice below is about fit, not the score.
What reviewers say
Prime Roof Repair
Prime Roof Repair handles emergencies with speed and honesty. When leaks strike from storms or flooding, they arrive fast, diagnose the problem clearly, complete the work the same day, and clean up after themselves. They stand out for saying no when repairs aren't needed and for staying in touch throughout larger projects like full replacements.
Staff member Arsen appears regularly in feedback for professionalism and single-day completion. Most callers report their calls and messages get immediate replies. Customers consistently mention fair pricing relative to quality, and one reviewer noted an inspection fee applies toward final repair costs.
High Skillz Roofing Inc.
Arthur and his team consistently respond fast to urgent leaks and complete jobs the same day or next day, with crews arriving on time, explaining work clearly, and leaving sites spotless. They handle skylight leaks, metal roof installations, flat roof replacements, and emergency storm damage with equal care, backed by fair pricing and follow-up photos that give homeowners confidence in the work.
Which should you pick?
Pick Prime Roof Repair if
- The problem is a skylight leak and you want a contractor with direct skylight repair experience
- You want an honest inspection first, with no pressure toward work you don't need
- You need fast, same-day emergency dispatch for an active leak
Pick High Skillz Roofing Inc. if
- The job is a full roof replacement rather than an isolated skylight fix
- You're in North York and want the owner directly on site managing the crew
- You want a crew known for finishing large jobs, and cleanup, in a single day
Verdict
The scores are nearly a wash (94.5 vs 94.4), so this comes down to the actual job. For a skylight leak or a targeted diagnostic visit, Prime Roof Repairs Company Toronto is the safer call, given its explicit skylight repair mentions and reputation for saying no when no work is needed. If the project is really a full roof replacement that happens to involve a skylight, High Skillz Roofing Inc. fits better, with Arthur's crew built around same-day replacements and thorough cleanup.
Need help deciding which contractor suits your project?
Describe your roofing work once and compare quotes from qualified roofing contractor in Ontario.
Enquiries you submit through our forms may be shared with partner providers who can carry out the work, and we may receive a referral fee. Our rankings and scores are based only on our published methodology and are not influenced by referral fees.
Frequently asked questions
- Which contractor has more direct skylight experience?
- Prime Roof Repairs Company Toronto, whose reviews specifically mention skylight repairs alongside leak and storm damage work.
- Which one is better for a full roof replacement rather than a skylight repair?
- High Skillz Roofing Inc., which is praised mainly for completing full roof replacements in a single day.
- Are the two similarly rated overall?
- Yes, both carry a 5.0 Google rating from over 200 reviews each and near-identical composite scores (94.5 vs 94.4).
- Which contractor is known for not upselling unnecessary work?
- Prime Roof Repairs Company Toronto is specifically noted for telling customers when a repair wasn't needed; High Skillz is praised for fair pricing and honest communication generally.